Search

Sunday, February 4, 2018

Dave Meltzer One Star Matches

Maze_ 6 hours ago
These are all the matches that have earned a Minus Five Star Rating (1-5) or a Minus Four Star rating (6-11) 
How many of them have you seen and what are your opinions on them? Do you agree with Big Money Meltz?

1. Hollywood Hogan vs. The Warrior – Halloween Havoc 1998
2. Los Villanos vs. Los Psycho Circus – Triplemania XXIII
3. Mr. T vs. Roddy Piper – Wrestlemania 2
4. The Bushwhackers vs. Nikolai Volkoff and The Iron Sheik – Heroes of Wrestling 1999
5. Junkyard Dog vs. Moondog Spot – WWF The Wrestling Classic 1985
6. Jenna Morascav.s Sharmell - Victory Road '09
7. The Warrior, Roddy Piper, Diamond Dallas Page vs Lex Luger, Sting, Kevin Nash, Stevie Ray, Bret Hart, Hulk Hogan - Fall Brawl '98
8. Sting vs Tony Palmore - Battle 7 1995
9. Sid Vicious vs The Nightstalker -Clash of the Champions XIII: Thanksgiving Thunder
10. The Bushwackers vs The Rougeaus - WrestleMania V
11. Hulk Hogan vs Andre the Giant - Wrestlemania III

Interesting to note: Hogan is on there 3 times.
Piper, The Ultimate Warrior, Sting and The Bushwackers are on it twice.

Who would have thought Sting and Bret Hart would end up on worst matches of all time lists?

I gotta say WTF at Wrestlemania III? Even if you don't like it because it was spectacle not skill... Minus 4 stars? One of the worst matches of all time? I mean like half the American roster was inspired by that match, the crowd went wild and it did great businsess. Hell Hercules vs Billy Jack was on the same show and he gave it 2.75 Stars, above average.

How you can say Hercules vs Billy Jack was not only better than Hogan/Andre but more than 3 times better is beyond me.