Search

Monday, August 7, 2017

Is Reigns the worst #1 since Hogan? Or do you believe Diesel was better?

  1. Boards
  2. Pro Wrestling: WWE
  3. Is Reigns the worst #1 since Hogan? Or do you believe Diesel was better?
EmDubyaSee 5 days ago#1
So, I mean, Roman sucks.... incredibly so. 

So it's factual he's way below Bruno, Backlund, Andre, Macho Man, Flair, Bret, Yokozuna, HBK, Austin, The Rock, Brock Lesnar, Hunter, Angle, Batista, Cena, Bryan as total packages.


But what about Nash and Hogan?

Now Roman is a better wrestler than Nash, and better than American Hogan, and a far worse promo than both.

Obviously Hogan is the bigger draw, as Diesel and Reigns are the two worst draws (by miles mind you) as the #1 guy. But in a combination of everything combined, was Diesel worse than Reigns, of course you have to go all the way to Hogan to find a worse overall guy? Or is Reigns himself in fact the worst #1 guy himself? 

(Note, I mean #1 according to the company, as in no way is Reigns actually the #1 guy currently, just as Luger never was despite the company saying he was)
Tom Bombadil: "you are probably the king of b8 dragonball fans at least!"
babyeatermax 5 days ago#2
Seth Rollins is the worst number one
This guy
Dean ambrose
Velvet Sky #1 fan
mrlowrider 5 days ago#4
So are you saying Luger is better than Reigns? Or he wasn't #1?
Ramses number one, he puts the people all on fire
https://imgur.com/a/S6BZ3
Dynedux 5 days ago#5
Yeah, Hogan was so bad as the top guy he turned the wwf into a household name and made it more popular than it ever had been before

Fucking. Internet. Nerds.
Noctis 906atk - 813.793.244
~700 atk Roberta chain
WarGreymon77 5 days ago#6
Dynedux posted...
Yeah, Hogan was so bad as the top guy he turned the wwf into a household name and made it more popular than it ever had been before

Also... TC forgot about Cena.
Doompa 5 days ago#7
lol at the TC thinking Hogan was a bad #1. Probably a CM Punk fan and has a Christian poster.
Never fear the strong, but never underestimate the weak.
EmDubyaSee 5 days ago#8
mrlowrider posted...
So are you saying Luger is better than Reigns? Or he wasn't #1?



He was never #1.
Tom Bombadil: "you are probably the king of b8 dragonball fans at least!"
EmDubyaSee 5 days ago#9
WarGreymon77 posted...
Dynedux posted...
Yeah, Hogan was so bad as the top guy he turned the wwf into a household name and made it more popular than it ever had been before

Also... TC forgot about Cena.



No I didn't. He is named right after Batista up there.
Tom Bombadil: "you are probably the king of b8 dragonball fans at least!"
Dynedux 5 days ago#10
EmDubyaSee posted...
mrlowrider posted...
So are you saying Luger is better than Reigns? Or he wasn't #1?



He was never #1.

Lmao

Literally stop posting
Noctis 906atk - 813.793.244
~700 atk Roberta chain
EmDubyaSee 5 days ago#11
babyeatermax posted...
Seth Rollins is the worst number one



He wouldn't be if he was. But he was never #1.
Tom Bombadil: "you are probably the king of b8 dragonball fans at least!"
EmDubyaSee 5 days ago#12
Dynedux posted...
EmDubyaSee posted...
mrlowrider posted...
So are you saying Luger is better than Reigns? Or he wasn't #1?



He was never #1.

Lmao

Literally stop posting


You think Luger was #1 at any point? 

Care to say when?
Tom Bombadil: "you are probably the king of b8 dragonball fans at least!"
EmDubyaSee 5 days ago#13
hanleYramirez02 posted...
Dean ambrose



Never #1. Just having the belt doesn't make you #1. I guess you could argue Dean was #1 for like 2 weeks. 

But if you put Dean as #1. Then Finn has to be too. And he would be a day... so
Yeah, Dean was never #1
Tom Bombadil: "you are probably the king of b8 dragonball fans at least!"
Doompa 5 days ago#14
EmDubyaSee posted...
WarGreymon77 posted...
Dynedux posted...
Yeah, Hogan was so bad as the top guy he turned the wwf into a household name and made it more popular than it ever had been before

Also... TC forgot about Cena.



No I didn't. He is named right after Batista up there.


Quit posting. Your opinions are invalid in thinking Hogan was a bad #1.
Never fear the strong, but never underestimate the weak.
Dynedux 5 days ago#15
EmDubyaSee posted...
Dynedux posted...
EmDubyaSee posted...
mrlowrider posted...
So are you saying Luger is better than Reigns? Or he wasn't #1?



He was never #1.

Lmao

Literally stop posting


You think Luger was #1 at any point? 

Care to say when?

The 6 months he was portrayed as top guy
Noctis 906atk - 813.793.244
~700 atk Roberta chain
mrlowrider 5 days ago#16
So what's that last paragraph? You saying reigns is in the company's eyes but not really and the same for Luger? And all those other #1s you listed that weren't number ones?

Your post is messy as fuck
Ramses number one, he puts the people all on fire
https://imgur.com/a/S6BZ3
Doompa 5 days ago#17
This TC is a IWC trainwreck.
Never fear the strong, but never underestimate the weak.
EmDubyaSee 5 days ago#18
Dynedux posted...
Yeah, Hogan was so bad as the top guy he turned the wwf into a household name and made it more popular than it ever had been before

Fucking. Internet. Nerds.


Macho out drew him, and beat him in every metric except politics. 

And this is overall package. Hogan had one thing he was beyond great at (drawing, but again, Macho outdrew him as a face) and another he was very good at charisma/showmanship. (His promos as a whole sucked, but god he could deliver them) He was between bad to terrible in everything else.
Tom Bombadil: "you are probably the king of b8 dragonball fans at least!"
Dynedux 5 days ago#19
EmDubyaSee posted...
Dynedux posted...
Yeah, Hogan was so bad as the top guy he turned the wwf into a household name and made it more popular than it ever had been before

Fucking. Internet. Nerds.


Macho out drew him, and beat him in every metric except politics.


Nice proof
Noctis 906atk - 813.793.244
~700 atk Roberta chain
mrlowrider posted...
So are you saying Luger is better than Reigns? Or he wasn't #1?


I'll certainly take Luger over Reigns.
mrlowrider 5 days ago#21
Is this whole post just you saying how much you hate hogan and reigns lol
Ramses number one, he puts the people all on fire
https://imgur.com/a/S6BZ3
mrlowrider 5 days ago#22
Skye Reynolds posted...
mrlowrider posted...
So are you saying Luger is better than Reigns? Or he wasn't #1?


I'll certainly take Luger over Reigns.

That's silly but it's your right to be silly
Ramses number one, he puts the people all on fire
https://imgur.com/a/S6BZ3
Doompa 5 days ago#23
EmDubyaSee posted...
Dynedux posted...
Yeah, Hogan was so bad as the top guy he turned the wwf into a household name and made it more popular than it ever had been before

Fucking. Internet. Nerds.


Macho out drew him, and beat him in every metric except politics. 


And I assume you don't have stats for this cause you're clearly pulling this out of your ass.
Never fear the strong, but never underestimate the weak.
EmDubyaSee 5 days ago#24
mrlowrider posted...
So what's that last paragraph? You saying reigns is in the company's eyes but not really and the same for Luger? And all those other #1s you listed that weren't number ones?

Your post is messy as fuck



Yes. The last paragraph is in fact saying in no way is Reigns actually #1, just as Luger never was. Despite the fact the company is/was begging for it. Everyone else I named 100% was #1, if only for a couple months, or in the case of Hogan.... way too many years. 

You can argue Taker was #1 for a couple months in 2002, with Rock gone, Austin gone, Lesnar being groomed. But there is an argument it was already Hunter. 

So I opted not to put him in.
Tom Bombadil: "you are probably the king of b8 dragonball fans at least!"
mrlowrider 5 days ago#25
So you're holding them to the same standard--number one to the company but not good enough to actually deserve it--then questioning how Luger would be an answer here?
Ramses number one, he puts the people all on fire
https://imgur.com/a/S6BZ3
EmDubyaSee 5 days ago#26
mrlowrider posted...
So you're holding them to the same standard--number one to the company but not good enough to actually deserve it--then questioning how Luger would be an answer here?



I'm not saying they don't deserve it (though Reigns doesn't, you can argue Luger, why he was able to get over in NWA/WCW twice like a super nova but not WWF, I'll never know) I'm saying they very simply aren't.... 

Reigns doesn't sell the most merch, doesn't move tickets for house shows, and has destroyed ratings while having people quit the network and then say the reason is Roman... that is not #1 guy no matter how much Vince tries to pretend it is. I have no clue who the #1 guy is right now, maybe it's AJ, maybe it's Lesnar despite the fact he is gone 3/4 of the year, hell, maybe it's still Cena. But it is not remotely Roman.
Tom Bombadil: "you are probably the king of b8 dragonball fans at least!"
mrlowrider 5 days ago#27
Then they were both flops despite their positioning as #1 guys

So Luger is still an answer

And Luger was worse
Ramses number one, he puts the people all on fire
https://imgur.com/a/S6BZ3
Doompa posted...
This TC is a IWC trainwreck.
He now exists in the darkness of deletion. Brother Nero is only a vessel of flesh that is empty on the inside. I deleted everything that made him special.
lilJoe457 5 days ago#29
Holy fucking shit. How clueless are you guys if you think Hogan was the worst number 1?

Do you know about wrestling TC? You can argue Hogan was the best number one. 

In. Ring. Work. Does. Not. Matter. For. WWE. Television. Charisma and character does. Something Roman doesn't have.
The sinister minister
Skye Reynolds posted...
mrlowrider posted...
So are you saying Luger is better than Reigns? Or he wasn't #1?


I'll certainly take Luger over Reigns.

Lol
{}Giants{}Knicks{}Isles{}Mets{}
Lex Luger was more entertaining than Roman Reigns.
Skye Reynolds posted...
Lex Luger was more entertaining than Roman Reigns.

Not riding around in the Lex Express he wasn't
{}Giants{}Knicks{}Isles{}Mets{}
mrlowrider 5 days ago#33
To you

I think Luger was fucking terrible and reigns is pretty fucking good.
Ramses number one, he puts the people all on fire
https://imgur.com/a/S6BZ3
EmDubyaSee 5 days ago#34
lilJoe457 posted...
Holy fucking shit. How clueless are you guys if you think Hogan was the worst number 1?

Do you know about wrestling TC? You can argue Hogan was the best number one. 

In. Ring. Work. Does. Not. Matter. For. WWE. Television. Charisma and character does. Something Roman doesn't have.


Yes it does you fricking Mark.... and if you believe it doesn't, tell me why the company (even before Hogan went racist) pushes HBK, Austin as the 2 best WWE guys ever (2 of the 4 best in ring on that list, the other being Bret who we know why he didn't get all his due, the other being DB who was #1 for some months only) and Flair as the best ever period. (The other guy in that too 5 for in ring technicians).

Tell me why all the major Landmark 10 Manias were MEd by the best worker in the company at that time (Bret, Shawn and Benoit, Bryan). It's all about the complete package. That's why so many people say Flair is the best ever, that's why HBK is said like 10 times more than Bret as best ever despite the fact Bret probably was slightly better in the ring.... Shawn was better at everything else. He was more complete than Bret. Hogan and Reigns are the least complete on that list.
Tom Bombadil: "you are probably the king of b8 dragonball fans at least!"
Lex was infinitely better as a heel
{}Giants{}Knicks{}Isles{}Mets{}
EmDubyaSee 5 days ago#36
Brandon_Jacobs posted...
Lex was infinitely better as a heel



This is definitely true.
But he did get over huge twice as a babyface in NWA/WCW.
Tom Bombadil: "you are probably the king of b8 dragonball fans at least!"
Brandon_Jacobs posted...
Skye Reynolds posted...
Lex Luger was more entertaining than Roman Reigns.

Not riding around in the Lex Express he wasn't


To be fair, I wasn't watching the WWE at that point. I might have tired of watching weekly updates of a guy traveling "this great country" in a bus. Just going by their ring work and respective characters, I find Luger more entertaining.

Roman has that X-Pac problem where he's continuing to act and dress like a member of a group that is defunct. He shouldn't be coming out to the Shield's music. He shouldn't be wearing that vest. And he shouldn't be pumping his wrist like a shotgun. It's not cool. And the whole selling point on his character is that he can take tremendous abuse. But that just means he kicks out of a buncha finishers and that's no fun. It's passive and it's dull.
A promo is something that a guy performs. Or they "give" a promo, so to speak. It's not what they *are*.
EmDubyaSee 5 days ago#39
DarkHorseRequie posted...
A promo is something that a guy performs. Or they "give" a promo, so to speak. It's not what they *are*.



While this is technically true.


He is a better/worse/good/bad promo is completely accepted and constantly said in wrestling vernacular.
Tom Bombadil: "you are probably the king of b8 dragonball fans at least!"
Worst #1 was HHH since he begat Roman Reigns by banging the boss's daughter, and then helping to promote his friends (see Sheamus and Roman Reigns).
When your reputation is ruined you can live quite freely.
Low Price Revolution
EmDubyaSee 5 days ago#41
MortimerBrewstr posted...
Worst #1 was HHH since he begat Roman Reigns by banging the boss's daughter, and then helping to promote his friends (see Sheamus and Roman Reigns).



Roman is Vince.

HHH has tried to push NXT, Mystico, Big E, Sheamus, Seth and Finn specifically, and maybe AJ.
Tom Bombadil: "you are probably the king of b8 dragonball fans at least!"
Dynedux 5 days ago#42
This is some grade A bait
Noctis 906atk - 813.793.244
~700 atk Roberta chain
Luger never won a single title (not even tag or intercontinental) during his WWE stint, how do people seriously think he was #1 at any time?
Dynedux 5 days ago#44
PunkRockGiik posted...
Luger never won a single title (not even tag or intercontinental) during his WWE stint, how do people seriously think he was #1 at any time?

Some of us are old enough that we lived through it
Noctis 906atk - 813.793.244
~700 atk Roberta chain
As the current chosen one, rains still lack the chosen one aura, especially with Joe right next to him.

But.......you think Hogan was bad?

The fuck?

Anyway rains has gotten better in-ring but he's a weak chosen one. But its partially Vince's fault as you gotta be either AJ-level in-ring or Joe-level on the mic to stand out. Brock, Strawman, K.O. and I guess New Day are the few things I care about.


As for the worse, I'd say 03 HHH, but it can be said it was Brock then so Diesel.

But even then, rains > Diesel
Imagine thinking Hogan was a bad #1 lmao.
This topic is shit. OP is a clueless casual.
What! The Farmclub! It's the mother f'ing -chika-chika- Farmclub!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sJr8QDBH-3E
redeyes6778 5 days ago#48
The only thing worse than diesel being #1 was Mable being groomed to be the next #1 guy at king of the ring
Tris10 5 days ago#49
At no point was Luger CLEARY number one.
In my eyes a true number one is winning more than one WM main event (on last) or a lengthly reign with a world title and you consistently closed most PPV's.
I wouldn't even say Punk was ever #1 as his defenses were always in the middle of the card and Cena always closed. Joint possibly, but I wouldn't count that.
How could Luger ever be #1 with Bret around? Sure he had the Lex express and slammed Yoko on that battleship, but the trigger was NEVER truly pulled. His greatest achievement was co-winner of a royal rumble.
So I don't think Luger was number one.
It drops deep as it does in my breath/
I never sleep, cus sleep is the cousin of death.....
redeyes6778 5 days ago#50
Luger's best moment was beating yokozuna via count out and celebrating like he had won the wwe title at summerslam
  1. Boards
  2. Pro Wrestling: WWE 
  3. Is Reigns the worst #1 since Hogan? Or do you believe Diesel was better?
    1. Boards
    2. Pro Wrestling: WWE
    3. Is Reigns the worst #1 since Hogan? Or do you believe Diesel was better?
    Dynedux 5 days ago#51
    Tris10 posted...
    At no point was Luger CLEARY number one.
    In my eyes...


    Well that's nice, in your eyes, but over here in reality
    Noctis 906atk - 813.793.244
    ~700 atk Roberta chain
    Tris10 5 days ago#52
    Dynedux posted...
    Tris10 posted...
    At no point was Luger CLEARY number one.
    In my eyes...


    Well that's nice, in your eyes, but over here in reality


    I'll happily admit I'm wrong if you can give me the rough time frame he was number one without question.
    It drops deep as it does in my breath/
    I never sleep, cus sleep is the cousin of death.....
    Dynedux 5 days ago#53
    Post WM through the summer and into the winter of... 93 was it? 94? Whichever year he became Captain America. He was clearly built as the top guy, portrayed as the top guy, paraded like the top guy... Then Vince had the steroid trial and he shifted the companies public image to smaller more realistically framed guys, and the era of Hart began
    Noctis 906atk - 813.793.244
    ~700 atk Roberta chain
    Dynedux posted...
    PunkRockGiik posted...
    Luger never won a single title (not even tag or intercontinental) during his WWE stint, how do people seriously think he was #1 at any time?

    Some of us are old enough that we lived through it

    This. Although 1995 is better off forgotten
    {}Giants{}Knicks{}Isles{}Mets{}
    Tris10 5 days ago#55
    Dynedux posted...
    Post WM through the summer and into the winter of... 93 was it? 94? Whichever year he became Captain America. He was clearly built as the top guy, portrayed as the top guy, paraded like the top guy... Then Vince had the steroid trial and he shifted the companies public image to smaller more realistically framed guys, and the era of Hart began


    I guess I'll eat my words. Despite never having won a title I guess by default he would be considered the top guy at that point.

    I wouldn't put him on reigns level though. Reigns has achieved more.
    It drops deep as it does in my breath/
    I never sleep, cus sleep is the cousin of death.....
    EmDubyaSee posted...
    mrlowrider posted...
    So are you saying Luger is better than Reigns? Or he wasn't #1?



    He was never #1.


    In Vince's eyes he was until Vince realised that the WWF audience were NEVER gonna take to him like they did Bret at that time.
    I'll get back up for good this time and I ain't comin' down...
    The Popo 5 days ago#57
    Luger was definitely the #1 for the stretch when he first debuted as the America-loving guy in place of the narcissist. He was chasing Yoko for the belt at a time when Hogan had just left, Bret was feuding with his brother forever, and Taker was in Giant Gonzalez purgatory. Shawn was still in the IC scene, Savage was part timing it as a commentator, and nobody else was even close to the top of the card. 

    Realistically, the only guys who could be called the #1 were Luger & Bret, and Bret would not take back the top slot until the end of Mania 10. It was just for a few months, but Luger was the top guy for that stretch.
    Live action Hungry Hungry Hippos though, now that was a sport. ~Aeon Azuran
    Bret/Owen didn't come to the fore until RR94, seeds planted at SVS93. And at that point Bret had Lawler in his face which didn't properly conclude for two years. (Lawler's arrest, which forced Shawn into the storyline as a substitute captain for the Knights)

    Vince tried to push Luger as hard as he could but WWF fans were not buying him. Also the Dopey Countout Celebration at Summerslam sort of hurt him. His last hurrah was WMX.
    I'll get back up for good this time and I ain't comin' down...
    Janpei 5 days ago#59
    The fact that you consider Hogan as one of the overall worst top guys is absolutely hilarious.
    www.twitch.tv/badguymaddox
    I enjoy playing single player games and chatting with viewers. Come say hi!
    Reigns is good. Topic is bad. 

    You literally said Yokozuna was the total package. Foreign heel too fat to move and couldn't speak English in Kayfabe so couldn't do promos. Yes please more main events with him. Lol
    http://www.last.fm/user/snoochtonooch
    official protector of Cuddles the kitten of the rock board
    (edited 5 days ago)quote
    EmDubyaSee posted...
    So it's factual he's way below Bruno, BacklundAndre, Macho Man, Flair, BretYokozunaHBK, Austin, The Rock, Brock Lesnar, Hunter, Angle, Batista, CenaBryan as total packages.


    He's better than the bolded IMO and definitely better than Andre and Yokozuna no questions asked.
    http://www.warwithwords.com
    Blade Forged in Darkness: An award-winning Fantasy Novel:http://www.amazon.com/dp/B01CE0TLLM
    Diesel is my pick for my least favorite babyface champion.

    As bland as Roman is, he at least loses from time to time. Diesel went undefeated from August '94 to October '95. Ultimate Warrior did as well during the ten months that he was chapion, but Diesel is worse because of the rivalry with Sid.

    After being undefeated for more than half a year, Diesel goes up against his villainous doppelganger... and clears all three matches over the course of the next three months. Like, what the hell? Diesel is due for a count out loss at that point and he sweeps a rivalry against a foe who has the same build, the same finisher, and a complimentary look? It's like, yeah, Nash is alright, but screw that title reign.
    Chubrock812 5 days ago#63
    Somebody give TC a bottle n put his ass to sleep
    You don't have to sell drugs to live like you sell drugs
    Yep, Diesel was boring as and only two good matches during his reign. First defence and his loss.
    I'll get back up for good this time and I ain't comin' down...
    Hardcore_Adult posted...
    Yep, Diesel was boring as and only two good matches during his reign. First defence and his loss.


    WrestleMania was a good match too.
    bigjclassic 5 days ago#66
    Doompa posted...
    lol at the TC thinking Hogan was a bad #1. Probably a CM Punk fan and has a Christian poster.


    Yeah, the Hogan shit is crap. Roman or Nash? Damn, but at least Nash had great matches with Bret, so Nash!
    PSN/steam: classicviolence Switch FC: 441991068406 3DS: 087719974865
    Gamefaqs: Home of mod-alts, shills, sock puppets, and mentally ill trolls
    Muflaggin 5 days ago#67
    Big Kev had a personality.
    GameFlux: Unofficial GameFAQs board browser
    EmDubyaSee posted...


    So it's factual he's way below Bruno, Backlund, Andre, Macho Man, Flair, Bret, Yokozuna, HBK, Austin, The Rock, Brock Lesnar, Hunter, Angle, Batista, Cena, Bryan as total packages.


    At no point were any of these guys number 1, except Flair if you count NWA. 

    And I love Yokozuna, but lol at Reigns being worse than Yokozuna.
    mrlowrider 5 days ago#69
    DarkDragon386 posted...
    EmDubyaSee posted...


    So it's factual he's way below Bruno, Backlund, Andre, Macho Man, Flair, Bret, Yokozuna, HBK, Austin, The Rock, Brock Lesnar, Hunter, Angle, Batista, Cena, Bryan as total packages.


    At no point were any of these guys number 1, except Flair if you count NWA. 

    And I love Yokozuna, but lol at Reigns being worse than Yokozuna.

    HBK was definitely number one. But the rest you're right on
    Ramses number one, he puts the people all on fire
    https://imgur.com/a/S6BZ3
    I feel like they wanted Angle to be a #1, but that gimmick was never going to be anything besides a heel in the AE.
    I got blisters on my fingers!!!
    Pink Floyd owns you all up in the face!
    DarkDragon386 posted...
    EmDubyaSee posted...


    So it's factual he's way below Bruno, Backlund, Andre, Macho Man, Flair, Bret, Yokozuna, HBK, Austin, The Rock, Brock Lesnar, Hunter, Angle, Batista, Cena, Bryan as total packages.


    At no point were any of these guys number 1, except Flair if you count NWA. 

    And I love Yokozuna, but lol at Reigns being worse than Yokozuna.


    Brian was briefly number one. As was Batista. And HBK was for a decent stretch.

    Savage kinda was. Kinda wasn't
    He now exists in the darkness of deletion. Brother Nero is only a vessel of flesh that is empty on the inside. I deleted everything that made him special.
    Reigns has been a lot better lately. People only hate him because he's #1. They always hate the #1
    Currently: Super Sm4sh Bros, Legend of Zelda BotW/ALBW, Pokemon Sun, Pooch & Yoshi's Wooly World, Bomberman R, Mario Kart 8 Deluxe, MHOmega, WWE 2K17
    Muflaggin 4 days ago#73
    Assassin2713 posted...
    Reigns has been a lot better lately. People only hate him because he's #1. They always hate the #1

    Nobody hates Okada.
    LightSnake: "Sigh....I might've been wrong about a lot this time."
    Terra-enforcer: "You were right. I was wrong. I'm a filthy welcher."
    1. Boards
    2. Pro Wrestling: WWE 
    3. Is Reigns the worst #1 since Hogan? Or do you believe Diesel was better?

No comments:

Post a Comment